Copyright © 2000 by Michael
Segers, All rights reserved
|
Me, Myself, and Irene Charlie
Baileygates/Hank - Jim Carrey Written
by Peter Farrelly & Mike Cerrone Directed
by Bobby Farrelly and Peter Farrelly Rated
R for sexual content, violence, crude humor, and strong language Runtime:
116 minutes |
The Patriot Benjamin
Martin - Mel Gibson Directed
by Roland Emmerich Written
by Robert Rodat Rated
R for violence Runtime: 164 minutes |
For
this hot summer movie season, two of Hollywood's hottest firecrackers, Jim
Carrey and Mel Gibson, bring distinctly different fireworks to your friendly
neighborhood megaplex. Carrey, after almost scaring old fans into thinking that
he had become a serious actor (in The Truman Show and Man on the Moon)
returns to his roots and rudeness, with enough physical comedy and weird facial
expressions for two characters in Me, Myself & Irene. He also returns
to collaboration with the Farrelly brothers, the Rodgers and Hammerstein of
grossness, who do for Rhode Island what John Waters did for Baltimore—and that
is not a good thing.
Perhaps
nodding to The Mask, Carrey has a chance to play two personalities in one
body. His character, a Rhode Island cop named Charlie, is a single father to
huge, black (it involves their mother's mutual Mensa membership with the
chauffeur who drove her and Charlie on their wedding day) sewer-mouthed,
brilliant triplets, who suddenly finds his inner pig. Me and myself work
together fairly well, but the problem is with Irene (Renée Zellweger). Somehow,
the Irene plot never works. Even with outright dumb and dumber comedies like
this, there has to be a solid intellectual underpinning. But, the Irene plot is
based on the idea that everyone thinks that Irene knows something about her
gangster ex-boss, while everyone knows that she doesn't.
Well,
Zellweger doesn't get in the way of Carrey's love affair with himself or his
split personalities' battle with themselves (himself? himselves?). This man is
amazing. In Man on the Moon he has serious critics talking about his
ability to "channel" the character he was playing. Here, he takes on
an actor's greatest challenge, to play not one but two characters at once.
But,
this movie has split personalities. One involves Jamaal, Lee Harvey, and Shonte,
Charlie's alleged kids. Smart, loving… these guys even kiss their scrawny
white daddy. Then, there is Charlie/Hank's poignant story of being the
long-suffering good guy. And, Irene's rather pointless story which must give
narrative drive to it all.
And,
you should know, each of these movie-lets shares a sheer offensiveness that…
Don't take my word for it. I sat fairly far up the aisle, one of two aisles, and
I counted five couples that stormed down the aisle complaining about the
grossness. Frankly, it just isn't that funny. This is the kind of film that
reminds me of Nietzche's dictum that "Every laugh is a cry for help."
Dying cattle, kids being held under water, thumbs being shot off—this is just
not the stuff that I want to laugh at. I wish I could have liked this film, but,
frankly, this film would not let me.
German
Roland Emmerich has been responsible for July fireworks before, with Independence
Day, and Mel Gibson (an Australian, remember) has made two other films that
cast a very dim light and a lot of blame on the British, Gallipoli and Braveheart.
Speaking of light, when I rambled around Francis Marion's land (some two
centuries later), it wasn’t permeated with the glow that it has in this film.
The
Patriot is the big film (at more than two and a half hours, a bit
too big) that tries too hard. Gibson's dead wife is too good, his house full of
kids too cute, and Gibson himself too noble. Maybe too lucky, since he and two
of his tikes wipe out a whole passle of Brits. All of this is a combination of
Francis Marion, South Carolina's "Swamp Fox," and Robert Rodat,
scriptwriter for Saving Private Ryan. While Carrey himself is almost
reason enough to sit through MM&I, Gibson, playing Gibson, is almost
reason enough not to see The Patriot.
Both
of these films are set up to be big-time money-makers, the kind that keep a hot
summer cool for the Hollywood moguls. So, who am I to complain? With the crude
body-fluid humor of MM&I or the crude manipulation of emotions (oh,
no, they aren't going to let the pretty girl die, are they?) of Patriot,
Hollywood is providing us an air-conditioned alternative to Fourth of July
fireworks displays.
Maybe
this summer of standing around watching each of two of the most boring
candidates for national office in a long time trying to prove that the other is
the more interesting, hence the less suitable to govern, we don't need any more
entertainment. We just need excuses to hide in the dark for a couple of hours
Mensa,
the organization for folks who score well on standardized tests, figures in the
plot of MM&I, so you might want to find out more about this odd
organization-
I
have often referred and linked to the many sites of About.com, and this time
out, I turn to their "18th Century History" site, first for
"American Revolution: General Information," a page of useful links-
http://history1700s.about.com/homework/history1700s/msub32.htm
Then,
for the e-text of "Life of General Francis Marion by Parson Weems"-
That
long URL and long text are interesting, because they give us a chance to see how
another age transformed the strange story of Francis Marion.
I
like to provide my readers with other perspectives on the films I review, not
necessarily perspectives that I share (and not necessarily perspectives that I
do not share), but here are the responses of other critics to this week's films.
First, here is Kevin Laforest (Norm at the Movies) on Me, Myself, and Irene-
http://www.projet9.netc.net/norm/archives/archive-m/me-i.htm
And
here is Dustin Putnam on The Patriot-
http://www.young-hollywood.com/Dustin/patriot.htm
Keep
your feet dry, your heart full of noble thoughts, and your eyes firmly set on
movies which, no matter how unpleasant they may be, are at least honest.